June 14, 2012
Andorra: The Ugliest Country in Europe?

Andorra makes no effort to charm those crossing the border from France. Shown here is the entry point into the commercial hub of Pas de la Casa. Photo by Alastair Bland.
If there had been a day long ago when the powers that be divided up the land and handed out the properties that would become Europe, I can imagine how the various recipients might have reacted. When the French saw their rolling hills and river valleys, they’d have knelt and handled the soil and declared that good wine would come of this land. And when the Italians saw their forests, they’d have anticipated the truffles and porcini and other wild fungi that would grow there. And when the Norwegians saw their proximity to the North Pole, they’d have known they would lead the world in Arctic exploration. And when the Greeks saw their many islands, they’d have foreseen their role in literature and lore as seafarers.
And when the Andorrans saw the mountainous lands that would be theirs, just upslope of Spain and south of France, I think I know what they’d have said:
“Crummy. It’s going to be tough to build shopping malls up there.”
Because building shopping malls seems to be the primary goal of the people of Andorra, that little landlocked nation smack in the rocky, craggy heart of the Pyrenees. Their secondary objective is apparently to deface their naturally beautiful land in whatever way is most convenient. Credit must be given, for they’ve succeeded in both enterprises. Entering Andorra via France, one encounters the ugliest town in Europe—Pas de la Casa, essentially a shopping complex and ski resort, with huge warehouse-like hotels and supermarkets stacked artlessly like shipping containers along narrow streets, where people eye the identical offerings of a hundred tax free junk stores. Other cement buildings seem abandoned, making them fair game for graffiti enthusiasts. The elevation here is 6,600 feet, and to reach the heart of Andorra, one must either take a highway tunnel south through the mountain or climb another 1300 feet over Col d’Envalira, the highest paved pass in the Pyrenees. I rode over the pass, arriving near sundown. On top was more astonishing ugliness—a handful of gas stations and the would-be spectacular view of the southern mountains nearly eclipsed by a McDonald’s sign posted beside the pass marker. Down the steep highway into the valley, I passed several towns consisting of cheap liquor and clothing outlets with a few hotels and restaurants.

On the highest paved pass in the Pyrenees, Andorra has planted a McDonald's sign---an indication of the country's lenience toward commerce. Photo by Alastair Bland.
The French had warned me that Andorra wasn’t pretty, but I didn’t believe them. How, I wondered, could a mountainous country, located smack between two of the most handsome countries in the world, be dead ugly? But Andorra is, and I would guess that Andorrans, should they read this, will bristle with a sort of pride—because clearly they haven’t sought to make their country pretty to the eye, though they had every chance. They had green mountains, with chamois and trout streams and wildflowers; they had cliffs and meadows and waterfalls; shoot, they even had the prettiest name in Europe, and they squandered it all. For one thing, Andorra has abandoned almost all endeavors agrarian (just 9,000 sheep live here; 100,000 live in the French Pyrenees). And so they grow a little tobacco, import nearly all their food and dedicate themselves to the shopping and services industries. With every slab of concrete they lay and every faux cobblestone they set and every neon light they plug in, they appear to have the goal of marring their landscape. They’ve succeeded grandly.
In France, a traveler may say to himself 30 times a day the following four words: “What a charming village.” In Andorra, such words are not spoken, at least not in that order. Instead, people say, “Cheap cigarettes!” and “Ten pairs of tube socks for 3 Euros!” and “Hooray, they’ve just opened a new perfume outlet in Canillo!”

Mountains, blue sky and sunshine cannot bring redemption to the artificial scenery of Andorra. Here, in the capital city of Andorra la Vella, the chief river of the valley flows over a bed of concrete. Photo by Alastair Bland.
One might say that Andorrans have done the best with what they have—a river canyon cut into a steep and largely rocky mountainside. I’ve seen official documents that call Andorra’s terrain—98 percent of it, to be exact—unsuitable for agriculture, but let’s keep things in context: That land is also unsuitable for perfume outlets and duty free liquor and jewelry shops. And so the Andorrans have crammed all that they hold dear into the available land that flanks their one major highway, which careens at a 10-percent gradient in places from the high pass all the way to Spain. Along the road’s shoulder are chain-link fences and concrete barriers. There are several picnic pullouts which have been carpeted with plastic turf. Billboards and name brands scream at travelers from every direction—McDonald’s, Pepsi and all the rest. But besides commerce, there are resident people here. About 90,000 people enjoy the privilege of calling themselves Andorran. They live in scab-ugly apartment buildings, smog-gray and five stories tall and which permanently block the sunlight from the streets below—which are remarkably noisy for such a small country. Here, Andorrans walk about briskly, attractive and slim as Italians, people who dress sharply, carry glitzy shopping bags and always, it seems, have somewhere to go. There is virtually no unemployment in Andorra. It’s a country both blessed and blistered by prosperity—and they can have it. I had a glance, I had the glory of climbing 6,000 vertical feet to see it, and now I’ve had all I wanted. I am sitting in an Andorran coffee shop now, looking at my map of Spain.
For those of you who don’t care to ever visit Andorra, who could blame you—but here are a few facts and figures on this funny little landlocked nation:
Size: 180 square miles (about four times the size of San Francisco).
Population: 84,300 in 2010.
Capital city: Andorra La Vella, population 22,000—and the highest capital city in Europe, at 3,356 feet.
Main agricultural crop: Tobacco.
Highest point: Coma Pedrosa, 9,665 feet.
Average altitude: 6,000-plus feet.
Wildlife: Includes trout, bears, eagles, chamois, foxes and ducks.
Armed forces: None. (Andorra’s only expense on weaponry is reportedly for ammunition used in ceremonial salutes.)
Main industry: Tourism.
Main tourist draw: Shopping.
Tourists per year: About 10 million.
Restaurants: 400.
Employment: One percent in agriculture, 21 percent in industry, 78 percent in services.
Sheep population: 9,000 (compare to 30 million in New Zealand).
Cow population: 1,100.
Horse population: 200.

From France, one sees Pas de la Casa ahead. Rather than turn and run, French shoppers flock to Andorra for the prospect of saving a few Euros on cigarettes, liquor, shampoo and glitzy clothing. Photo by Alastair Bland.
Sign up for our free email newsletter and receive the best stories from Smithsonian.com each week.
8 Comments »
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI
























Hey, I live in Andorra and it is a beautiful, peaceful, friendly and safe country with amazing facilities. The whole country has the population of Scranton city, Pennsylvania and the capital, Andorra La Vella is smaller than Prichard city, Mobile. But it has to cope with an incredible 9 million visitors a year.
The main ‘drag’ is the single thru road from Spain to France and the majority of day tourists hit the cheap malls to stock up on duty free gas, cigarettes and alcohol. These locations are best avoided of course; the high volumes, cents-in-the-dollar profit margins and small population means the country can invest in a low tax, high health lifestyle for its lucky inhabitants. All away from the tourist trap commercial areas. Many live in the pretty villages in other valleys or hidden in the hills away from the passing crowds. I have never seen so many beautiful walks or hikes for every ability, meticulously marked and maintained, empty of folk in unspoilt mountains.
Ten to fifteen minutes drive (yes it has to be a 4×4) from my mountain hideaway, high in the hills in the next valley, I can be in Illa, the new shopping small center voted Europe’s best in 3 categories this year or in the ski resorts during the winter months. Spa’s, gym’s, auditoriums, medical facilities, life expectancy! All these are world beating too.
In this tiny population, I can buy the best wines of France and of Spain, choose from French cheeses and Spanish olive oil. Oranges from Seville or croissants and bread from the Dordogne. Rabbit caught in the local forests or pure beef from the small Andorran herds of 10 or so cows apiece – and all in a small local supermarket with 3 aisles. It has the best of 3 countries.
Of course the traffic is not just one way. I go to the market a short drive over the Spanish border every week and to the organic farmers market in France. The difference in style – both produce and lifestyle is astonishing. And all just half an hour or so in each direction. I can either finish my shopping with a ‘canya’ and tapas or cafe and croissant, depending on which country’s cafe I sit down in.
From my house I can see unadulterated mountains of pine and ash, the far distant cable car taking skiers to the pistes or bikers to their mountain trails. In the middle is a tiny little near thousand year old church perched on a precipice with eye-witness wall carvings of our first duty free visitor – Hannibal’s crossing from Africa on the way through Andorra to sack Europe.
Last weekend’s thunderstorm reverberated around the mountain peaks for hours, knocking out all satellite TV but bringing Andorra’s myriad window boxes of rouge-red geraniums a much needed drink before resuming the weeks blue skies and baking sun, low humidity and fresh pure mountain breezes.
So, all in, I think the powers that be gave me one of the most enviable locations to live and lifestyle to pursue in Europe. My advice? If you visit, be sure to look in, up and away!
Harsh, but true. I went to Andorra long ago, and all I remember was buying cut-rate perfume.
Comment from the author: Hi Vinn – I saw the high mountains above the valley, and I have no doubt whatsoever that there are some wonderful things to be experienced up there. However, travelers on bikes can’t be expected to push up one-way roads in the hope of seeing a pretty stream or village. In other places, beautiful scenery is available from the main highway, and if Andorra wished its visitors to see the natural and cultural beauty of the place, they should have left out the billboards and warehouses full of junk for sale. Perhaps someday I’ll take a hike in the Andorran high country. I’m sure it would be splendid. Until then, best regards.
Alastair
I work in Andorra and I agree that it is an ugly country. Otherwise, if the Governments and the people had worked to preserve its natural beauty and identity, Andorra would be a sweetest land. There are too much big buildings, roads, houses, shops, malls… and it is polluted. The natural beauty is now in the highest mountains, where no constructions were build.
I would say it is possibly uglier than the ugliest parts of the US.
Hi, i’am andorran and I partially disagree with you.
GOing from france to spain crossing only the highways and te main streets ain’t visiting Andorra!!
May be, if you come again I could show you the other 98% of land (which as you said is not available for construction, Ordino, Pal, Casamanya comapderosa and Hundreds more of places. As you said we partially live from tourism so by this article you unnecessary harm our reputation without knowing well our country.
You could talk abaout thaht is the only county in Europe that never had a war, slaves, colonies or so many other bad things that our neighbours had or even have.
For this reason and because i’m openning an Hotel in october 2012, I invite you to come again, and it will be for free!! not just tax free ;))
This is one of the worst articles from Smithsonian in recent times. It is biased by an author that dislikes everything that represents capitalism. I have been in Andorra and it lacks the boredom of some French villages and it is more cosmopolitan than most midsize European cities. From an American perspective there is nothing wrong with Andorra. It marries modern facilities with nature without jeopardinzing any of them.
Thanks for the comment, but I have to object. Andorra has not married modern facilities with nature; rather, it has built modern facilities in spite of, or regardless of, nature. Also, I don’t dislike capitalism, as you say. When I travel, I anticipate villages and towns precisely because I can stop and buy things–usually just groceries, coffee, cheese, wine and the like from small locally operated businesses. That is capitalism that I feel enhances a culture and a landscape. However, Andorra is out of control. Along its only main road, one finds miles of billboards, shopping centers and glitzy perfume outlets–plus, there is a McDonald’s sign at the top of the highest paved pass in the Pyrenees, which I felt to be a sort of breach of public trust. Other nations in Europe boast thriving economies and yet have not marred the sight of their nations with commercialism in its ugliest forms the way that Andorra has.