September 7, 2010
Can IDW Redeem Jurassic Park?

The cover of IDW's Jurassic Park: Redemption, issue 2.
Ever since the flop that was Jurassic Park 3, rumors have circulated about a bigger, badder fourth sequel in the dinosaur franchise. In the past two years alone the project has gone from officially dead to a prospective project Universal might develop once a few other big-ticket films are completed. But comic publisher IDW is not waiting around for the studio to get into gear. This past summer they have launched their own five-part Jurassic Park: Redemption series in an attempt to find a new way to bring people and dinosaurs into conflict.
Set a decade and a half after the first incident, IDW’s new series primarily focuses on what has become of the two children who were on the island during the tragedy—John Hammond’s grandchildren Lex and Tim. Despite the tragedy, both appear to have done well. Lex, the founder of an organic produce corporation, spends much of her time lobbying world governments to keep up security on the still-dinosaur-infested islands, while Tim is a political power-broker who is working with a shadowy businessman to start a tamer version of Jurassic Park with only herbivores. A holding facility in Texas—run by the geneticist Dr. Wu and an obvious caricature of the real-life paleontologist Robert Bakker named “Dr. Backer”—is keeping the dinosaurs until they are ready for their big debut, but what Tim doesn’t know is that the new park’s scientists bred carnivorous species, too. Carnotaurus and Velociraptor are among the predatory dinosaurs kept at the facility. I think you can see where this is going.
So far, the series is only two issues deep, but the story arc is not all that surprising. It is a veritable rule of dinosaur fiction that if a large theropod is seen in Act I, it should be on a bloody rampage by the start of Act II. After all, this would not be a Jurassic Park series if the dinosaurs were content to stay in their enclosures, and, since the escaped Carnotaurus is partial to beef, the blood and gore it leaves in its wake set the local people to wondering what kind of monster is prowling the countryside. Attempts to capture it repeatedly fail, and somehow I get the feeling that it won’t take long before other dinosaurs make a break for it, too.
As for the artwork in this series, it runs the gamut from “pretty good” to just plain awful. The people, buildings, and other objects in the story are done well—glossy while also a little rough around the edges—but the dinosaurs are terrible. Not only are all of them painted with drab shades of olive green and brown, but some of them don’t look anything at all like their real-life counterparts. The renderings of Velociraptor, especially, are so bad that it is hard to believe—they look like guys in rubber suits trying to impersonate raptors, and there’s not a feather to be seen on them. IDW would have done better to get Brett Booth to draw their dinosaurs, and it is a shame that, in a series centered around dinosaurs, the stars of the series look so terrible.
I’ll pick up this thread again when the next issue of Jurassic Park: Redemption arrives in the mail, and will keep up with it through the end of the series.
Sign up for our free email newsletter and receive the best stories from Smithsonian.com each week.
10 Comments »
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI






















Yeah, I’ve been completely unimpressed by the artwork.
Here’s a tip for anyone thinking about publishing a dinosaur comic:
The artwork is all that matters. I don’t care what convoluted devices you use for your plots or how lacking in nuance your characters are. Just make the dinosaurs look awesome. That’s it!
Also, the fact that Dr. Wu was eaten alive by raptors in the original JP novel might send some purists over the edge…
Totally agree with David on this one. The art of this series is unforgivable. I bought the first issue, but won’t be buying any others.
They should have talked to William Stout or Ricardo Delgado.
I haven’t seen the actual books, but I do have to give the artists credit on one point: they put bristles on their Triceratops. At least on the cover of the issue pictured here. That being said, I don’t know why you’d do the right thing (I say “right” assuming that the paper on filamentous integumentary structures in Triceratops will be hitting the shelves soon) in one place, and the wrong thing in so many others.
@ #4, probably someone unconnected to whoever did the interior was hired for the cover illustration, and typically only the best get to do covers. The comics whose covers and interiors are done by the same person are pretty few and far between.
Thanks for the review, I had no idea there was a JP comic. I’ll have to wander over to the Silver Snail comic shop and check it out.
[...] Can IDW Redeem Jurassic Park? [...]
I dont think JP3 can be considered a flop: with a budget of $93 million it earned over $360 million, making it among the highest grossing films of 2001 (and received generally favorable reviews). Far from Jurassic Park 1 numbers, but still nothing to sneeze at.
As for the comics, I agree the artwork leaves much to be desired. Would it have been so hard for the artists to do some research and capture the “Jurasic Park style”? The best part of the old Topps series is that they took great care to ensure the characters and dinosaurs matched the distictive look of their movie counterparts that we are familiar with.
I am enjoying the covers of the new comics, however. (There are different cover variants for each issue, for those interested.) Most of them are quite good. An especially colorful issue #5 cover even features fully feathered raptors, attacking what appears to be an acrocanthosaurus along with a marine reptile in a melee of prehistoric terror. Good times.
I was less bothered by the appearance of Wu (after all, he never died in the movie and that’s the canon the comic is using) and more bothered by the fact that the Dr. Bakker look-a-like is back. After dying quite messily in the second movie. That’s almost unbelievably lazy. Ditto the artwork.
Thanks Brian!
I did try to get on a JP a few weeks ago. I was told they were all booked up.
Best,
Brett