October 31, 2012
Hints and Honors
The contest is over, but The Great American History Puzzle lives on!
If any of you got stumped on a puzzle or two — or are just getting started — and would like some help to get to the finish, we’ve put up a series of hints for each puzzle on the main puzzle page. Don’t worry, you can hit that link without fear of seeing spoilers–you need to click on the links listed there to reveal each hint in turn.
There are three hints for each puzzle, starting with a gentle nudge and escalating to a pretty muscular shove. You can also see full, comprehensive solutions for each puzzle as well.
I’m told that 49 solvers submitted a correct set of answers between Jeffrey Davidson’s winning entry and our announcement closing the contest. Very impressive!
Here’s the official Honor Roll listing all 49 people who submitted correct answers and the order in which we received them. Like Jeffrey, some of these solvers had figured out the final puzzles in advance, and so there was a dramatic sprint to the finish line, as you can see. The first 20 runners-up will receive one-year subscriptions to Smithsonian magazine in special recognition of their accomplishment.
While we’re naming names, I also wanted to give a shout-out to the people who helped me with the contest: Eric Berlin, Peter Gordon, Stanley Newman, and Trip Payne, who helped test-solve the puzzles; Bill Heller, who gave me a crash course in Logic Puzzles 101; and Miranda Jennings (my sister!) who was my very patient origami coach. And of course to the Puzzle Team at Smithsonian. My deepest thanks to everyone! (Any mistakes in the puzzles, of course, are my responsibility and not theirs.)
But my most heartfelt thanks go to all you solvers who have spent this month grappling with the twists and turns of these puzzles. I had a blast working on them, and I hope this new round of hints means that they’ll continue to entertain and challenge a whole new audience in their post-contest afterlife. Tell your friends.
Is this good-bye? Well, maybe, but maybe not forever. We had so much fun that the Smithsonian Great American Puzzle might just return next year. Stay tuned…meanwhile, tell us what you think.
Honor Roll:
October 22, 2012
- 2:00:20 PM — Jeff Davidson – Winner
- 2:00:25 PM — Dan Katz
- 2:00:26 PM — Stan Park
- 2:00:27 PM — Francis Heaney
- 2:00:30 PM — Scott Rogoff
- 2:00:30 PM — Jeffrey Harris
- 2:00:32 PM — Michael Sylvia
- 2:00:35 PM — Patrick Blindauer
- 2:00:36 PM — Christopher Denault
- 2:00:36 PM — Mark Halpin
- 2:00:39 PM — Sandy Weisz
- 2:00:39 PM — Carrie Temple
- 2:00:50 PM — Nathan Curtis
- 2:01:11 PM — Craig Harman
- 2:01:23 PM — Joon Pahk
- 2:01:25 PM — Anonymous
- 2:01:45 PM — Ed Seiler
- 2:01:46 PM — Anonymous
- 2:02:49 PM — Jennifer Kidder
- 2:04:15 PM — Andy Bouwman
- 2:37:24 PM — Yar Woo
- 2:52:11 PM — Robert Cook
- 3:10:52 PM — Jan Chong
- 3:22:57 PM — Christopher Michaud
- 6:06:28 PM — Matt Pavlovich
- 6:37:43 PM — The Beaky Family
- 7:31:28 PM — The Who Do You Think You Are? Research Team
- 9:04:19 PM — Kelly Wade
- 10:57:11 PM — Diana Yost
October 23, 2012
- 2:31:06 AM — Joe Bain
- 6:02:41 AM — J. T. Williams
- 11:32:52 AM — Robert Yost
- 1:42:30 PM — Nancy Taubenslag
- 2:56:00 PM — Mykal Duffy
- 3:48:38 PM — Mike Tice
- 4:43:05 PM — Barbara J. Martin
- 5:45:46 PM — Edward Samuels
- 5:46:00 PM — Jennifer and Richard Galas
- 5:51:05 PM — Coreen Steinbach
- 10:45:38 PM — Kiran MacCormick
October 24, 2012
- 10:11:44 AM — Wendy Mulligan-Steckler
- 12:38:24 PM — Bob, Kimberly, Max, Nick & Jack Dabagia
- 5:40:39 PM — Clive Dawson
- 5:51:37 PM — Jeffrey Shih
- 9:25:44 PM — Mark & Emily Horansky
October 25, 2012
- 8:48:38 PM — John Sokolovic
- 8:51:19 PM — Stephanie Brubaker
- 8:58:55 PM — William Smith
October 26, 2012
- 10:48:41 AM — Susan Day
Sign up for our free email newsletter and receive the best stories from Smithsonian.com each week.
9 Comments »
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI







Never, in a million years would I have figured out the President Puzzle ( Puzzle #8).
Would any of the early solvers care to comment on how
they actually solved the puzzles? Some of the posted
solutions seem far-fatched, to say the least.
Congratulations (from a dropout) to Jeffrey and all the finalists. Well done.
Ken/ Puzzle Team, can you tell us how many TOTAL participants there were up until the contest deadline? I guess there might be more now that the shouting is over.
Just curious: How many of the “finalists” listed were already subscribers to Smithsonian magazine?
none of them are far-fetched, although it certainly helps to have experience with this sort of thing. with free-form, instructionless puzzles, you have to always be asking yourself questions like “what is the pattern here? what do these things have in common? is there a particular code suggested by the text or images in the puzzle? what else can i do with what i’ve been given?” lateral thinking ability is a must.
Ahhh! All the hints AND answers posted at once? I don’t have that kind of will power!! But now that the answers are posted, I see just how close I was on the ones I didn’t get solved… Even though I cursed Ken Jennings’s name often throughout this experience, I am thoroughly glad I participated. I have learned that attitude is an important element to puzzle solving, and I like to think I would be more patient with myself and get less frustrated next go ’round… PLEASE let there be a next go ’round!
Thanks for the experience!
I now realize it is Miranda upon whom I should heap my scorn due to that damned origami mess!! I am hoping I will have a year to work on my folding skills for next year’s (?) contest. I may have to enter a Zen monastery to achieve the proper focus . . .
I ran out of time but totally enjoyed these puzzles for all their frustration and education. My neglected boyfriend asked if I wanted to go to the museums next weekend since I didn’t win 10 grand in cab fare. Lmao He just doesn’t understand. :/
I also didn’t have the willpower to look only at the hints and not the solution.
I did have great fun on the whole. I figured out puzzles 1 through 7, and I was on the right track for puzzles 9 and 10.
This was my first time at really being involved in a “treasure hunt” using puzzles. Thank you for posting the hints and answers because I see now how completely off base I was with many of the puzzles, but going through the solutions makes me feel that I have oh so many more tools for the next time around!! Congratulations to all who solved the puzzles this time. All I can say is WOW!