Blogs

  • News
  • |
  • Art
  • |
  • History
  • |
  • Food and Travel
  • |
  • Science
Dinosaur Tracking

Where paleontology meets pop culture

Hominid Hunting

Meet the members of the tangled human family tree

Innovations

How human ingenuity is changing the way we live

Surprising Science

Ideas, news and discoveries from the world of science


April 16, 2012

UPDATED: How Humans Cause Earthquakes

Some scientists have suggested the weight of water in the lake created by the Zipingpu Dam in China triggered the 2008 Sichuan earthquake (courtesy of flickr user TaylorMiles)

Update on April 16, 2012: A new study by the U.S. Geological Survey to be presented Wednesday indicates that the “remarkable increase” in earthquakes in the continental United States that rate greater than 3 on the Richter Magnitude Scale is “almost certainly manmade.” The authors note that although it is unclear whether new hydrofracturing (a.k.a. fracking) techniques to recover natural gas are to blame, “the increase in seismicity coincides with the injection of wastewater in deep disposal wells.” —Joseph Stromberg

On Saturday, a magnitude 4.0 earthquake shook eastern Ohio, a week after a smaller temblor in the region worried officials so badly that they halted work on a fluid-injection well in Youngstown.

This wasn’t the first case in which the injection of fluids into the earth has been linked with earthquakes. In April, for example, the English seaside resort town of Blackpool shook from a magnitude 2.3 earthquake, one of several quakes now known to have been caused by hydraulic fracturing (or “fracking,” which involves pumping large amounts of fluid into the ground to release natural gas) in the area. The link has been known for decades—a series of quakes in the Denver, Colorado, region in 1967 was caused by fluid injection.

The phenomenon is so well known that Arthur McGarr, a geologist at the U.S. Geological Survey in Menlo Park, California, has developed a method to predict the highest magnitude of an earthquake that could be produced by hydraulic fracturing, carbon sequestration, geothermal power generation or any method that involves injecting fluid deep into the earth. Though the method doesn’t allow scientists to predict the likelihood that such a quake would occur, it will let engineers better plan for worst-case scenarios, McGarr told Nature.

Hydraulic fracturing naturally causes small tremors, but bigger quakes may occur if the liquid migrates beyond the area where it’s injected. The New York Times reports:

The larger earthquakes near Blackpool were thought to be caused the same way that quakes could be set off from disposal wells—by migration of the fluid into rock formations below the shale. Seismologists say that these deeper, older rocks, collectively referred to as the “basement,” are littered with faults that, although under stress, have reached equilibrium over hundreds of millions of years.

“There are plenty of faults,” said Leonardo Seeber, a seismologist with the Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory. “Conservatively, one should assume that no matter where you drill, the basement is going to have faults that could rupture.”

Earthquakes caused by fracking are of particular interest right now because the number of wells, particularly in the United States, has been skyrocketing (along with reports of nasty environmental consequences, such as flammable water). But this is only one way that humans are causing the earth to quake. Mining (taking weight from the earth), creating lakes with dams (adding weight on top of the earth) and extracting oil and gas from the earth have caused at least 200 earthquakes in the last 160 years, Columbia University earthquake scientist Christian Klose told Popular Science.

Klose’s research has demonstrated that coal mining was responsible for Australia’s most damaging earthquake in recent memory, the magnitude 5.6 Newcastle earthquake of 1989. And in 2009, he was one of several scientists who suggested that the magnitude 7.9 earthquake in China’s Sichuan Province in 2008, which left 80,000 dead, could have have been triggered by the Zipingpu Dam. (That wasn’t the first time a dam was linked to an earthquake—Hoover Dam shook frequently as Lake Mead filled.)

It can be easy to look at our planet and think we’re too small to really do much damage, but the damage we can do can have severe consequences for ourselves. ”In the past, people never thought that human activity could have such a big impact,” Klose told Wired, “but it can.”



***

Sign up for our free email newsletter and receive the best stories from Smithsonian.com each week.

10 Comments »

  1. radrob says:

    http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=EZtJAAAAIBAJ&sjid=jQwNAAAAIBAJ&pg=3973,2288696&dq=earthquakes+in+denver&hl=en

    The nice thing about google news is that you can look up past events pretty easily to research your piece. Earthquakes from disposal wells are not new. There’s a planned one happening in Oregon for geothermal.
    The link above is from a famously referenced series of quakes that happened in Denver

  2. david says:

    what are the chemicals in the tracking fluid? I would like ti read a list of the names of the chemicals.

    Thank you.

    david

  3. david says:

    What are the chemicals in the Fracking fluid? I would like to read a list.

    Since I will be drinking them in the near future, I would like the corporation (s) who are injecting them into our water tables to tell me what those chemicals are.

    Is that asking too much?

    thank you.

  4. Mango Punch says:

    To what extent could human caused earthquakes actually be a good thing, relieving built up pressure and preventing larger more damaging earthquakes later?

  5. Mary Briggs says:

    It’s funny really. We are the smartest of all animals and yet we do not think of things like this. We do not think of smaller animals, insects, birds. They are wild but live in the cities. They must eat, but we give no thought to that. Not as a community, city, nor state. Even though their health is linked to our own. We are sooo smart.

  6. Unfortunate truth says:

    You won’t be able to find a list of the chemicals in the fracking fluid. If my memory serves me correctly Dick Cheney (when he was Vice President) helped push through some bill that allowed companies not to disclose what exactly is in the fracking fluids.

  7. Rose says:

    http://www.straterra.co.nz/Chemical%20additives – site about fracking in NZ from a trying to sell it as good point of view… but gives information on chemicals used. Fracking is under discussion in NZ due to overseas companies wanting to come here and do it and locals worried about water contamination/earthquakes etc

  8. JAS says:

    Interesting article – wish there was some data so we can evaluate the issues of correlation and causation. As it is, we are left with the author saying “trust me.” I prefer “trust but verify.”

  9. All Shook Up says:

    JAS – You don’t have to take the author’s word for it. Deep injection wells to have been linked with a marked increase of earthquakes in several states, including Colorado, Texas, Oklahoma, Arkansas, Ohio, and West Virginia. When use of the wells stopped, so did the unusual earthquakes. Put Google to work and you can read about it yourself.

  10. Sue says:

    I keep wondering if our building codes will need to change all over the world to now build to an earthquake code. This will increase the cost of construction not to mention embodied energy of extra steel and concrete. I am sure this use of energy would outweigh the energy obtained from this method of extraction.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until Smithsonian.com has approved them. Smithsonian reserves the right not to post any comments that are unlawful, threatening, offensive, defamatory, invasive of a person's privacy, inappropriate, confidential or proprietary, political messages, product endorsements, or other content that might otherwise violate any laws or policies.

Spam protection by WP Captcha-Free

Advertisement



Follow Us

Travel with Smithsonian






Advertisement