Blogs

  • News
  • |
  • Art
  • |
  • History
  • |
  • Food and Travel
  • |
  • Science
Dinosaur Tracking

Where paleontology meets pop culture

Hominid Hunting

Meet the members of the tangled human family tree

Innovations

How human ingenuity is changing the way we live

Surprising Science

Ideas, news and discoveries from the world of science


November 30, 2012

Why Does the Durian Fruit Smell So Terrible?

Durians have a notorious aroma likened to rotting meat, turpentine and gym socks. Image via Wikimedia Commons/Kalai

If you’ve smelled a durian even once, you probably remember it. Even with the husk intact, the notorious Asian fruit has such a potent stench that it’s banned on the Singapore Rapid Mass Transit. Food writer Richard Sterling has written “its odor is best described as…turpentine and onions, garnished with a gym sock. It can be smelled from yards away.”

A small minority, though, love the smell and taste of the fruit. Anthony Bourdain calls it “indescribable, something you will either love or despise…Your breath will smell as if you’d been French-kissing your dead grandmother.” The fruit’s flesh is sometimes eaten raw, or is cooked and used to flavor a number of traditional Southeast Asian dishes and candies. It’s also used in traditional Asian medicine, as both an anti-fever treatment and a aphrodisiac. Our “Off the Road” blog profiled a pair of intrepid travelers on a year-long journey planned around tasting different varieties of durian.

Durians are banned on Signapore’s mass transit, among other public places, because of their potent scent. Image via Wikimedia Commons/Steve Bennett

What everyone can agree on is that the fruit’s odor, whether pleasant or dreadful, is uncommonly potent. Now, in a new study in the Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemistry, a group of scientists from the German Research Center for Food Chemistry has attempted to figure out how exactly the fruit produces such a powerful stench.

In breaking down aroma extract, taken from Thai durians, with a mass spectrometer and gas chromatograph, the team, led by Jia-Ziao Li, pinpointed 50 discrete compounds in the fruit responsible for its uncommon aroma. Those compounds included eight that hadn’t been detected in durians before—and four compounds that had been completely unknown to science.

Their analysis suggests that it is not any single compound but instead the mixture of different chemicals that produces the fruit’s powerful stench. The compounds are identified by their chemical formulas, which are likely cryptic to anyone without a degree in organic chemistry (1-{[1-(ethylsulfanyl)ethyl]sulfanyl}ethanethiol, for example), but the research team associated each one with a particular odor.

What’s interesting is that none of the compounds individually seem to match with the characteristic durian smell—they range widely, and include labels like fruity, skunky, metallic, rubbery, burnt, roasted onion, garlic, cheese, onion and honey. A number of them have been detected in just a few other substances, such as cooked beef, yeast extract, dried squid and leeks. Somehow, the combination of these 50 chemicals produces the powerful scent that has entranced and repulsed people the world over.

Even apart from the smell, durians are a scientific marvel. According to a 2009 Japanese study, durian extract strongly inhibits the enzyme aldehyde dehydrogenase (ALDH), used by the liver to break down alcohol. This might account for a piece of traditional Asian folklore: that getting intoxicated while eating durians can lead to death.



***

Sign up for our free email newsletter and receive the best stories from Smithsonian.com each week.

13 Comments »

  1. Jon says:

    The big compound you mentioned is a sulfur compound, so that seems like a pretty big indication that something will smell funny.

    So endeth my contribution to the conversation.

  2. Jess H says:

    It smells like a rotting dog corpse full of maggots in the height of summer. Despite that fact, I tried to taste it once. It tastes like spicy pineapple sorbet. A strange, strange fruit.

  3. Bill says:

    Durians certainly do smell bad, but the taste? Just heavenly! One of the richest, most complex and delightful tastes in the world. Who would have thunk it?

  4. Crocodile Chuck says:

    A malaysian once explained it to me: “Like eating strawberries and cream out of a filthy commode’

  5. Barbara Piper says:

    An predictable article that explains how the durian smells, but it does not explain why it smells “bad”. An article on why humans respond to certain smells as “bad” would be more interesting. Simply reducing a smell to a chemical formula does not tell us anything about the complex psychology of smell, or why humans react to some smells differently than other mammals do. A lost opportunity here.

  6. Lindsay says:

    Good to see another study on durian! For such a strange fruit, there is a surprising lack in research. I would also like to see studies on the odor of non-Thai durians, which are typically much stronger smelling than the Thai durians. The odor of other durian species is even stranger. Durio Graveolens smells to me like bubblegum and pimento cheese. Truly bizarre.

  7. Randy says:

    The first time I went to Thailand the hotel I stayed in had a sign by the elevator that said “No Mangosteens or Durians allowed in the rooms.” I was upset to think that the hotel would not allow the ethnic minority Mangosteens and Durians the right to rent rooms in their hotel until I found out that they were fruits and not people.

  8. Alderina says:

    I’m Indonesian and a durian lover. For me, the smell of durian is very very very very good. It’s the king of fruits!

    But I understand that this sentiment is not widely common in Western countries ;)

  9. Durian Lover says:

    I LOVE DURIAN VERY MUCH <3.
    I don't know y people hate durians smell. Do you guys ever try to eat the fruit?
    Try…
    in 1 … 2… 3 …. you forgot about your problem
    in 4…..5……6…. you know that heaven exist…

    -RP

  10. didut says:

    – A small minority, though, love the smell and taste of the fruit –

    Small minority?!? Mate, lot of Indonesian people will love to eat this durian once a year because this fruit not available at any season. And believe me number of Indonesia inhabitan is not small !

  11. Nona says:

    I really love durians. I’m from Indonesia where you can find durians almost everywhere at the supermarkets.. and personally I think the smells of durian is not that bad (doesn’t like gym socks, at least :p) I love local durians, but also Thai durians because I think they had very strong taste that local durians doesn’t have. Oh my.. I think I should go grab some durian pancakes (which is very famous in here at the moment) at the nearest fruit market, like right now. LOL!
    Nice article btw :)

  12. Zenstrive says:

    Everyone in Asia loves durians. Only caucasians and who pretend to be caucasians who hate durians.

  13. Herbal Ed says:

    Re. the supposed aphrodisiac property of durians: There’s an old saying in Thailand: “When the durians are falling, the sarongs are rising.”

    Re. “A small minority, though, love the smell and taste of the fruit.” It’s definitely way more than a “small minority” … Here in Bangkok most of my Thai friends not only like durians … the LOVE them. For me … an American … I’ve developed a taste for them but can only eat so much. Not so much because of the odor but because they are so rich and I satiate quickly.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until Smithsonian.com has approved them. Smithsonian reserves the right not to post any comments that are unlawful, threatening, offensive, defamatory, invasive of a person's privacy, inappropriate, confidential or proprietary, political messages, product endorsements, or other content that might otherwise violate any laws or policies.

Spam protection by WP Captcha-Free

Advertisement



Follow Us

Travel with Smithsonian






Advertisement