November 6, 2012 11:42 am
Bee Hive Democracy Isn’t So Different From Human Democracy
Photo: kokogiak
Amidst the chaos and excitement of election day, Slate wonders, can we take a hint from the animal kingdom in order to smooth out our process of selecting a leader and reaching consensus?
Bees’ election system is probably most like our own. Honey bee hives are usually somewhat democratic. Bees weigh new nest options by a site’s size, humidity and presence of surrounding flowers, and individuals vote on their favorite nest site with intricate dances.
When it comes to choosing a leader, a queen assumes her position one of two ways. Either she kills all of her potential competitors before the helpless victims emerge from their royal cells (probably not the way we want our political system to work), or the workers coax rivals out of their cells and force all contestants to duel (perhaps the bee equivalent of a debate). The ultimate winner of all of the duels becomes the queen and takes over the hive. Unfortunately, the losers are unceremoniously killed and thrown out of the nest.
The workers do have a say-so in which of the dueling queen emerges as the hive’s new leader. When scientists removed dueling queens from the presence of their future subjects, the bigger bee always won the fight. However, when they allowed the queens to battle with the workers surrounding them, the bigger queen did not always win. In other words, the workers somehow influence the duel outcomes, preventing the matches from simply being a shoo-in for the largest contestant.
What about other examples of leader-selection from the animal kingdom?
- Fire ant queens take part in brutal battles-to-the-death that can last hours.
- Wolves beat, pummel and bit their way to the top of the pack for gaining hierarchy.
- Termites rely on extreme nepotism; when queens die, they are replaced by exact clones.
The moral? When it comes to animal democracy, we should probably take a hint from the bees, but without the sacrificial slaughter of fallen contestants.
More from Smithsonian.com:
The Real Birth of American Democracy
Designing Democracy Around a Ditch
Sign up for our free email newsletter and receive the best stories from Smithsonian.com each week.
1 Comment »
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI
That is the WORST titles for an article!!!! Comparing bees to humans in any way is naive. Bees colonies act as a unit where human civilization is a bunch of individuals running around for themselves. Human democracy is brutal and extremely unfair where bee colonies are precise and aimed at forwarding the entire species. Queens are chosen by the colony for more than one reason. Those reasons are far to numerous for any one explaination, besides, it would be naive and ignorant for a human being to project ourselves on to a colony for comparison.
Comment by bill castro — November 7, 2012 @ 6:26 am